Dude, Where’s My Willpower?

by Darrin on December 2, 2010

Where’s Your Willpower, Dude?

Have you ever felt that you are in a constant battle with your body? That it wants nothing more than to lose muscle and gain fat, when you want it to do the exact opposite?

And no time more than when you’ve been heeding the advice of your favorite health guru to eat less and exercise more?

You’re not alone in your frustration. It all comes down to willpower. And more specifically, the lack thereof.

Running on Empty

Imagine this scenario: due to a worldwide shortage of fossil fuels, the government mandates that you can only fill up the gas tank of your car once every month, on the first Saturday.

Since very few people can make a tank of gas last that long, you will need to carefully allocate your car usage. Walking, biking, and public transportation will probably start playing a bigger role in your daily life. And when you do get to drive, you will want to use the most efficient route to get all your errands done.

Fuel and Willpower

More and more evidence is coming out illustrating that willpower is a lot like gasoline in that hypothetical world: a scarce commodity that, once utilized, is gone forever.

I’ve posted this video before, but it is worth seeing again:

You should also check out this article, which further brings the issue of limited willpower to light.

It even plays a major role in why most people don’t have their financial lives together, as Ramit Sethi explains in this recent New York Times article.

In my last post, I brought up the concept of the conscious and unconscious minds. Willpower acts as the scarce “fuel” of your conscious mind, while the unconscious runs on a vast amount of “renewable energy” in the form of instincts and habits.

The reason that “eat less, exercise more” doesn’t work is that it puts all the responsibility on the conscious part of your mind, all the while fighting a grueling battle with the unconscious, which is almost always a losing battle.

The Missing Key to Your Health and Fitness

I don’t see many health and fitness experts talking about what a key concept this is, but I think it is huge.

The reason so many guys struggle to lose their beer bellies and start packing on muscle is obvious: they are burning all their willpower on other pursuits, and setting themselves up to struggle, and ultimately fail, at “eating less and exercising more.”

These two recommendations are essentially demands that you focus more of this scarce resource on your health and fitness.

But what if you are busy as hell with work, school, family, or other goals that use up your willpower? This is what most health gurus neglect.

The only reason the participants in The Minnesota Starvation Experiment lost so much weight on their “low calorie” nutrition and exercise program was because they were forced to stick with it every day! They lived under close watch on the University campus and had all their meals prepared by others and given to them.

They had no choice, and therfore invested no willpower.

But the devastating health consequences these men experienced, including the rapid fat gain once they stopped the experiment, shows that we must not just look for another way to simply cut calories.

The key to getting into the best shape of your life lies not in conscious calorie restriction, but instead in:

  1. Transforming your surroundings to reduce harmful temptations.
  2. Building rituals that automatically promote and sustain your health and fitness.
  3. Making slow, steady progress every day.

This could very well be the cornerstone of the entire LMVM philosophy. Imagine being able to eat well, get plenty of exercise, and get lots of rest and relaxation, with as little willpower invested as possible. That’s the goal of this site, and I’ll be damned if you don’t get there if you keep following along!

Wrapping Up…

The best health and fitness program must both:

  1. Give you the results you want (muscle growth, fat loss, etc.)
  2. Be sustainable long-term.

In this series, I have shown you that the conventional wisdom of conscious caloric restriction tends to violate that second condition, leaving you hungry and tired, zapping you of willpower, and resulting in a never-ending battle against your body.

Thankfully, there is a better way.

I’ve been throwing a lot of theory at you so far. But theories are only as good as they can be successfully applied in the real world.

In the next few installments, I’ll present you with ideas of how to eat better, move smarter, and relax harder to optimize your health and fitness as effortlessly as possible, without burning out of willpower!

{ 6 comments }

Raymond - ZenMyFitness December 3, 2010 at 5:06 am

Interesting topic that I ‘ll have to think about cause the first 2 points are opposite of what I think;
1)To transform my surroundings is not to challenge myself to be in control, if I have to change my surrounding (out of sight out of mind).
2) Rituals are habits .. habits are the worse thing in Zen as there is no awareness just running on auto pilot I miss the experience.
But I’m happy watch you develop your points further to see if they fit within my reasoning.
Raymond

Srdjan P - Bloom to Fit December 4, 2010 at 8:54 am

This is really cool!

The relation between your willpower and gasoline for your car is very interesting.

Thanks for sharing those links, very cool articles.

Dave - Not Your Average Fitness Tips December 4, 2010 at 4:29 pm

Awesome way to pull together a lot of what you’ve talked about lately. Temptation is always a challenge for me, especially this time of year. In general, I’ve tried to limit temptations. The first step in my process was Eat Stop Eat. Once I found a “diet” that wasn’t really a diet, I started losing weight. Since then, I’ve gradually eliminated the unhealthy foods that I used to it. Sure, I’ll indulge in treats when I go out or on special occasions, but I’ve found my best willpower is just not having anything around. This obviously didn’t lead to rapid weight loss, but in my opinion, slow and steady does win the race in this case.

Alykhan - Fitness Breakout December 4, 2010 at 4:35 pm

Darrin,

Great analogy. I agree that willpower is a lot like scarce fuel. But when you switch the focus of something from conscious to unconscious, the fuel supply becomes unlimited. This focus switch is the real key to obtaining long-term health and fitness.

Alykhan

Alejandro "The Fittest Vegan" December 7, 2010 at 6:02 pm

Nice!!

Its so true that its hard to have any available willpower if there are too many things that take over your brain. even if you do make it into the gym you are unlikely to lift strong because you’re spending your time thinking about everything going on in your life that you lose focus.

I look forward to reading more about it.

Darrin December 9, 2010 at 7:51 am

@Raymond:

I’d say most people’s habits are definitely detrimental – they aren’t getting them anywhere near where they want to be going in life. But we are all doing things unconsciously all the time – and I think if you can take advantage of that, you can come out ahead. By knowing what you want, you can establish the habits that will get you there with much less hassle. Kinda like having automatic deposits into a retirement account!

@Srdjan:

Glad you enjoyed the links. I’ve been geeking out over this concept for a while now and am excited to find a way to apply it to health, fitness, etc.

@Dave:

Yeah, I have NO willpower when it comes to food! This halloween, we had a bowl of candy set up for trick-or-treaters for about a week. And EVERY DAMNED TIME I walked by that thing I grabbed another mini candy bar! After a couple of headaches and stomachaches, I just had to hide the thing in the cupboard.

I do think that the idea of a “diet” in most people’s minds is that it is a temporary thing – they are able to put up with the restrictions at first because they figure they’ll drop their weight quickly and can return back to “normal” food. Not feeling deprived is one big clue that a diet is sustainable for life.

@Alykhan:

Fo reals. It’s just like learning how to ride a bike, difficult at first, but once you get it, you’re set for life.

@Alejandro:

…or watching one of the 1,001 TVs that they have there! 🙂

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: